PofoliaShared via Pofolia

Oxford University Press eBooks· 2013· Book chapter

Social Ontology

Raimo Tuomela

Short summary

This book presents a theory of social ontology centered on 'we-thinking' and 'we-acting' (we-mode), distinguishing it from individualistic 'I-mode' thinking, and argues this framework is superior for understanding large organized groups and group reasons.

AI-generated from the title and abstract; the full text is not read.

Key points

  • Introduces a 'we-mode' framework for collective intentionality and group agency, distinct from individualistic 'I-mode'.
  • Presents large organized groups (states, corporations) as functionally organized agents with externally constructed intentional states.
  • Develops a theory of group reasons based on members' participatory reasons.
  • Argues via game-theoretical reasoning that the we-mode approach is conceptually and rational-functionally superior to individualistic approaches.

AI-generated from the title and abstract; the full text is not read.

Abstract

The main focus of this book about social ontology is collective intentionality (as expressed by joint intentions, wants, beliefs, and action) and group agency. The theory presented starts from the intuitive distinction between thinking and acting as a private person (“I-mode”) versus thinking and acting as a group member who identifies with the group and typically engages in “we-thinking’’ and joint acting (“we-mode”). The conceptually group-based we-mode framework expresses full-blown we-thinking and we-acting. A group with we-mode members is regarded as a functionally organized group agent whose intentional states are externally constructed normally by the group members. The group agent account has practical descriptive and explanatory value especially in the case of large organized groups (e.g. states and corporations) concerning group action as well as intergroup cooperation and conflict. The we-mode approach is extended to cover groups controlled by external authority such as is the case in many corporations. The book gives the first full-blown theory of group reasons in the sense of members’ participatory reasons as distinguished from a group agent’s reasons for action. Importantly, the book argues in terms of game-theoretical group-reasoning that the we-mode approach is both conceptually and rational-functionally different from what an individualistic approach is capable of even in group-friendly “pro-group I-mode” cases. Other central topics covered in the book are the ontological nature of group agents (such as corporations and states) and large groups in general, group solidarity, cooperation in groups, and relevant aspects of the history of collective intentionality. In all, the book accordingly offers major contributions to the study of social ontology from a philosophical perspective.

The authors' abstract, as published at the source. Oxford University Press eBooks, 2013 · DOI ↗

TakeawaysPremium
Ask the paperFree account

Continue with a free account

Ask the paper: 3 free questions a day about this paper; save it, get its citation, new summaries every day for your field. Takeaways are Premium.

Continue free on the web

Sign in with Google or Apple; no card needed. You come back to this paper.

On your phone:

Field: History and Philosophy of Science

History and Philosophy of ScienceArts and Humanities