Impact assessment of earthquake early warning systems in Central America

Abstract

Earthquake Early Warning (EEW) systems aim to alert users in advance of imminent shaking, enabling them to take action. In collaboration with local seismic agencies, the Swiss Seismological Service (SED), has developed national EEW systems across Central America. Public EEW alerts are now available, considering the frequent seismic activity and the vulnerability of the building stock, EEW has the potential to reduce casualties (i.e. fatalities and injuries). In this study, we build upon a probabilistic framework to quantify the potential benefits of EEW systems in reducing casualties. For each event generated in the stochastic catalog (100,000 event sets), we estimate the number of casualties in the absence of EEW. The framework evaluates the potential casualty reduction attributable to an operational EEW system, considering the expected warning times in each event at the target site, the subsequent actions taken upon receiving the alert, and system performance. For a return period of 475 years, the fatality reduction could reach ∼14% to 17% corresponding to hundreds fewer fatalities in Costa Rica and Nicaragua, and thousands fewer fatalities in El Salvador and Guatemala. From this baseline scenario, we explore strategies to improve casualty reduction: (1) increase warning time by densifying the seismic network; and (2) compare the effectiveness of Drop, Cover, And Hold On (DCHO) versus evacuation as recommended protective actions. Our results suggest that evacuation is a suitable strategy for reducing fatalities in this region, given the prevalence of single-story structures. Given the available warning time, evacuation is advised for occupants on the first floor, and those on upper floors should adopt DCHO. Our findings indicate that the implementation of EEW leads to a ∼10% reduction in average annual fatalities. A cost–benefit analysis reveals that the economic benefits of public EEW systems significantly outweigh the associated costs, making EEW a cost-effective mitigation strategy.

The authors' abstract, as published at the source. Earthquake Spectra, 2025 · DOI ↗