JLIS it· 2026Q2
Cultural heritage objects in lack of anchoring communities. An unfinished reflection on a relational ethics of care
- 0citations
- Q2SCImago
- 2026year
Short summary
Care for colonial-era Ethiopian manuscripts should temporarily prioritize digitization and open access over physical repatriation when originating communities no longer exist or are in civil war.
AI-generated from the title and abstract; the full text is not read.
Key points
- The return of colonial-era cultural artefacts is complicated when originating communities no longer exist or are in conflict.
- Ethiopian manuscripts taken after the Battle of Maqdala serve as a case study for these ethical dilemmas.
- The article questions the premises of unconditional calls for repatriation.
- It proposes prioritizing the care and accessibility of heritage objects via digitization and open access as a provisional alternative to physical return.
AI-generated from the title and abstract; the full text is not read.
Abstract
The return of cultural artefacts taken during the colonial era seems to be a matter of course in our time. But what happens if the communities to whom these objects should be returned have for long ceased to exist and their successors are involved in a civil war? At the example of manuscripts taken from Ethiopia after the Battle of Maqdala, this contribution discusses ethical, legal and social issues (ELSI) surrounding such cultural heritage objects and calls into question the premises of recent calls for their return. This article discusses the history of these manuscripts and the case of missing “anchoring communities”, reconsiders provisional alternatives such as digitisation and provision in open access, and argues in the sense of an ethics of care. Consequently, an individual, rights-based approach to archival ethics is set aside and the care for the object itself is temporarily prioritised over the physical repatriation of the cultural heritage item.
The authors' abstract, as published at the source. JLIS it, 2026 · DOI ↗
The rest is in the Pofolia app
Takeaways and questions to the paper; new summaries every day for your field. Free.
Sign in on the web to openSpace and Planetary ScienceEarth and Planetary Sciences